Fwd: Re: hakka: re: Hakkologists, please reply

["John Guo" <hakka98@hotmail.com>]

>
>Albert,
>
>I read your Yet centric view, it sounds too TI for me.
>You are more Tainwanese than Hakka. Well, environment changes people.
>
>>Dear Mr. Chung:
>>I am not Hakkalogists but I will make some comments anyway.
>>The part related to Taiwan still have inaccurate points, as I 
discussed
>>with you before.  The people came with Cheng Cheng-kung or mitrated to
>>Taiwan during Cheng's era should not be mostly Hakka.  Cheng and his
>>followers mainly came from southern Fuk-kien. Otherwise, Hakka will 
not
>>be such a minority in Taiwan now.  Some of the towns you mentioned
>>are not Hakka town. 
>>
>>I read the two books about the origin of Hakka by Professor Lo 
>Hiong-lim
>>(used Hakka pronounciation)carefully. The migration story especially 
>the
>>first two are based on very litte evidences. I will suggest everyone 
>read 
>>following informations if you are interested in Hakka origin.
>>
>>1) Dr. Liu Zinfad's posting in Hakka Forum on 2/14 (The origin of the 
>name
>>Hakka),  2/17 (Hakka identity revisited), 2/20 (definition of Hakka), 
>6/13
>>(Hakka genetics and others), 12/27 (Cantonese/Hakka linguistics)
>>
>>2) Professor Fong Hok-ka's book  " Deep Investigation of the Origin of
>>Hakka " ( mainly archeology and sociology view points)
>>
>>3) Robert Ramsey: The Language of China (Princeton U. Press, 1987):
>>linguistics view points
>>
>>Prof. Lo made a comment in this book that blood type study should be
>>done in future to help to determine the origin of Hakka.  The modern
>>studies either by immunolobulin genetics, HLA typing or other studies 
>by
>>different investigators point to the fact that Hakka's ancestors are 
>mainly
>>from southern China and only very small numbers migrated from North.  
>>
>>I summaried or quoted some information from Lo, Fong and Ramsey's
>>books in my homepage too.  You are welcome to visit (no Honsii fonts
>>necessary, written in English):
>>
>>http://www.i1.net/~alchu/hakka/toihakka.htm
>>
>>Thanks, Best Regards.
>>Albert Chu
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>====================================================================
>>Hakka Global Network mailing list (hakka@mini.brooklaw.edu)
>>Subscribe: mail majordomo@brooklaw.edu with body "subscribe hakka"
>>Unsubscribe: mail majordomo@brooklaw.edu with  "unsubscribe hakka"
>>
>
>
>______________________________________________________
>Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
>
>====================================================================
>Hakka Global Network mailing list (hakka@mini.brooklaw.edu)
>Subscribe: mail majordomo@brooklaw.edu with body "subscribe hakka"
>Unsubscribe: mail majordomo@brooklaw.edu with  "unsubscribe hakka"
>


______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com